Stock SIP vs. Mutual Fund SIP: Is Investing in Individual Stocks a Waste?

 

A few months ago, I finally started earning on my own, and like many new professionals, I was excited to start investing. I began with a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) in mutual funds—it felt smart, disciplined, and simple.
Then, I decided to try a SIP in direct equity (individual stocks). It seemed like the next logical step. But a casual comment from a colleague stopped me in my tracks:
“SIP in equity is a waste.”
That sentence stuck with me. Is it really? I decided to dig deeper to clear up this common confusion, so you don't have to scratch your head like I did.

💡 Let’s Clear a Common Confusion: What SIP Really Is

First things first: SIP is just a way of investing, not the investment itself.
It means you invest a fixed, regular amount—usually monthly—instead of one large lump sum. You can apply this method to almost any asset, including mutual funds, direct stocks, or even gold.
The real power of the SIP method comes from a concept called Rupee Cost Averaging (RCA).
In simple terms, RCA means you buy more units when prices are low and fewer units when prices are high. This process automatically lowers your average cost per unit over time and smooths out the inevitable ups and downs of the market .
The goal of a SIP is simple: to stay consistent, avoid timing the market, and build wealth over the long term.

📈 Mutual Fund SIP: The Beginner's Best Friend

When most people talk about SIP, they are referring to a SIP in a mutual fund. This is the default recommendation for new investors, and for good reason.
A mutual fund is essentially a professionally managed basket of stocks or bonds. When you invest through a SIP, you are benefiting from three key things:
1.Automatic Diversification: Your money is spread across dozens of companies, which significantly reduces your risk. If one stock performs poorly, the others can cushion the blow.
2.Professional Management: Fund managers are constantly researching and monitoring the market, so you don't have to.
3.Simplicity and Low Effort: You set it up once, and the discipline is automated.
These advantages make mutual fund SIPs an incredibly effective and low-stress way to gain exposure to the equity market.

📌 Stock SIP: The High-Risk, High-Reward Path

A Stock SIP simply means you invest a fixed amount regularly into one or more specific individual stocks.
So, is it a waste? No—it’s not a waste, but it is a different game entirely.
While a Stock SIP also benefits from Rupee Cost Averaging, it comes with a major trade-off: You are the fund manager.
Feature
Mutual Fund SIP
Stock SIP (Direct Equity)
Diversification
Automatic (across many stocks)
None (only the stocks you pick)
Management
Professional Fund Manager
You (The Investor)
Risk Exposure
Lower (due to diversification)
Higher (full volatility of chosen stocks)
Required Effort
Low (Set-and-forget)
High (Requires in-depth research and monitoring)
Potential Return
Moderate to High
Potentially Higher, but also Higher Risk of Loss
Stock SIP can be worth it if you enjoy researching companies, are comfortable with market volatility, and are in it for the long term (5–10+ years). However, if you prefer an automated, diversified approach and don't want to watch the markets regularly, a Stock SIP is likely not the best fit for you.

💭 My Take: What I Decided

Calling Stock SIP a "waste" is oversimplifying something that depends entirely on your personal goals and temperament.
For me, SIP in mutual funds will remain my core long-term strategy. It’s simple, disciplined, and reduces the chance of making emotional mistakes. It gives me exposure to the equity markets without the heavy, constant research.
At the same time, I might experiment with small Stock SIPs in companies I truly believe in—not because everyone says so, but because I now understand the risks and the rewards.

🧠 Final Thought: Ask the Right Question

Instead of asking:
❓ “Is SIP in equity a waste?”
Ask this:
👉 “Does this fit my goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon?”
That’s the real question.
At the end of the day, investing isn’t about proving someone right or wrong—it’s about finding the strategy that works best for you and helps you stay invested for the long run.

References

[1] ICICI Bank: Rupee Cost Averaging: What it is, Why it Matters
[2] DSP Mutual Fund: How Rupee Cost Averaging Benefits Your Mutual Fund SIP
[3] Edelweiss Mutual Fund: Stock SIP vs Mutual Fund SIP: Meaning and Key Differences

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

🌍 How to Start Investing in 2025 (Beginner’s Global Guide to investing)

Image
  💸 Turn ₹500 or $10 into Wealth—No Suit, No Stress, No Excuses. 🧠 Still Think Investing is Just for Rich Guys in Suits? Let’s smash that myth-for good In 2025, you don’t need a fancy finance degree, a six-figure salary, or a Wall Street jargon. All you need is a working internet connection or Wi-Fi, ₹500 or $10, and this blog. Whether  you’re scrolling instagram during your chai break(tea) in India, chilling in Toronto, or commuting in London— you can start investing and not just for the sake of it — but to actually build real, long-term wealth that gives you options in life. 🌱 1. What Even Is Investing? (The Lazy Friend’s Explanation) Saving = Storing money. Investing = Growing money. Think of investing like planting a seed. You water it, wait, and—voilà—a tree that gives you shade and fruit. That’s what stocks, ETFs, and index funds do. You plant once, and over time—your money grows, multiplies, and works for you. ⚡ 2. Why Start Now? (Even if You're Br...
Read more

Index Funds vs ETFs in 2025: Which One Should You Choose as a Beginner?

Image
Introduction I still remember the day I put ₹10,000 into my first index fund. It was 2016, I was fresh out of college, clueless about investing, and terrified I'd lose it all. I didn’t know how stocks worked or what NAV meant—I just knew I had to start somewhere . I chose the Nifty 50 Index Fund—mainly because someone on YouTube said it was “safe” and “simple.” I forgot about it. No tracking, no trading, nothing. Just ₹10,000 sitting in a fund. Fast forward to 2025—when I checked the value last month, it had grown to nearly ₹29,000 . That’s almost 3x growth in 10 years , without me lifting a finger. No picking up stock. No stress. Just time, patience, and the magic of compounding. In the US, the story’s just as powerful. A $1,000 investment in VOO (S&P 500 ETF) in 2015 would be worth around $2,700+ today—again, without any active management. That’s the power of index investing . Whether you choose an index fund or an ETF, the real win is just getting started—and sta...
Read more

Can You FIRE in India? What We Can Learn From the US Movement

Image
I’m not lazy — I just don’t want to work 9–5 until I’m 60 to finally start living. Sound familiar? If you’ve ever stared at your screen mid-shift wondering, “Is this really it for the next 40 years?” — Welcome to the club. We're the side-hustle generation. The mentally drained but still hustling generation. chasing freedom over burnout. We don’t just want to survive our 30s — we want to own them. That’s where FIRE comes in — Financial Independence, Retire Early — a movement that’s part personal finance, part rebellion, and totally possible (yes, even in India, even in rupees).  What Is FIRE , Really? You’ve probably seen people throwing around the term “FIRE” like it’s some kind of a  secret club. It stands for Financial Independence, Retire Early — but it’s not just about quitting your job at 40 to sip coconuts on a beach. At its core, FIRE is about freedom . Freedom to choose how you spend your time. Freedom to walk away from a toxic workplace....
Read more